There is a big difference in what some sellers sell as "seconds", versus others. I have heard a lot of stories about products bought from certain big sellers of seconds in respect to deformities, big weight deviation, etc. That said - I have bought probably 30,000+ seconds from Shooter's Pro Shop (all Nosler product) and it is hard, if not impossible, to distinguish them from first line bullets. I have weighed them, inspected them, etc. - but more importantly shot them. I use them for practice in my target rifles and by the thousands when shooting at varmints. They group as well and perform as well as any other bullets I have used. I also haven't heard any bad news of Nosler seconds. I can say that I've never tossed any that looked bad - so that is something. I don't know this for a fact (this is the internet!) - but I'm pretty sure Nosler doesn't let the crap bullets out of their manufacturing facility, whereas with some other manufacturers - that seems to not be the case. I've heard bad stories of blems coming out of Midsouth and Natchez. I don't know the brands they sell - and I've not bought them from Midway either. seems some of those sellers expect you to sort out the crap bullets (and there may be a lot of them in some lots). If ordering up some blems from a new place, I certainly wouldn't order a lot of them the first time.