amlevin said:
J-rod said:
PS h4350, 52.5gn, 185 hybrids, 2.288 to ogive, win brass, cci br2's gives me 2950fps and excellent accuracy. So yes it does work
In a 308????
My thought too! A 185 at 2,950 fps produces 3,223 ft/lb ME, the same as a 155 at 3,223 fps MV and the 230 Hybrid at 2,646 fps MV.
A general rule of thumb is that a rifle / barrel / cartridge combination will produce similar muzzle energies with different bullet weights assuming the chamber is appropriately throated and the correct grade of propellant used for the bullet weight + usable case volume. So, this puts a 185 at this claimed MV into perspective.
I know people who produce some impressive MVs / MEs from 308 Win, but combinations that produce over 3,200 fps MV safely with 155s are in the rarely seen to fairytale category, and the few who get close to there spend a large part of their income replacing barrels and cases.
ESPECIALLY when it's claimed from a relatively slow burning single-base powder where it'd be difficult to get enough into the case even to simply produce enough energy to achieve that velocity and muzzle energy.
I know QuickLOAD isn't anything like 100% accurate, but I thought I'd have a play to see how the most optimistic scenario might model in this case. To wit:
Very thin-wall case in a very slack chamber - 58.0gn overflow water capacity. (Winchester is 57gn after firing in my 'minimum SAAMI' chamber).
34-inch barrel
throat such that the bullet is barely nipped into the case - 3.100" COAL, only 67 thou' of shank held in the case-neck.
54.0 gn H4350 which is calculated as 111.6% fill-ratio. In practice, such a shallow seated bullet wouldn't stay in the neck most likely with that degree of powder compression, but we'll imagine it does.
Since my version of QuickLOAD doesn't include the Hybrids, I've used the 185gn Juggernaut, but I doubt if the findings are overly affected.
And the result? ........ 2,954 fps from a 34-inch barrel, so getting there or thereabouts, BUT at 66,068 psi chamber pressure or a 10% overload. In other words, proof cartridge pressures.
Incidentally, because powder A is shown as having a similar burning speed to powder B, this emphatically DOES NOT MEAN THEY WILL PERFORM THE SAME IN ANY CARTRIDGE / BULLET SITUATION, OR EVEN GUARANTEE PERFORMING SIMILARLY.