• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

On the subject of bronze brushes versus nylon.

Personally, I think people shouldn't comment on cleaning procedures if they aren't checking with a borescope.
Wouldn’t it be more important to check cleaning procedures against actual live fire performance?
Scott Young
 
Wouldn’t it be more important to check cleaning procedures against actual live fire performance?
Scott Young
Well, yes.
What I was trying to say is without seeing what the actual condition of the bore is, you really don't know how clean or not it is.
I think it would be easier to correlate a condition in the bore to accuracy on target than just some cleaning procedure [without knowing what the actual condition in the bore is].

And, let's be honest, most/many of the posts about cleaning are focused just on getting the bore clean - without any reference to results on target. My point here is that if you aren't looking at the results of the cleaning, you just don't know what works to get the bore clean or not.
 
Well, yes.
What I was trying to say is without seeing what the actual condition of the bore is, you really don't know how clean or not it is.
I think it would be easier to correlate a condition in the bore to accuracy on target than just some cleaning procedure [without knowing what the actual condition in the bore is].

And, let's be honest, most/many of the posts about cleaning are focused just on getting the bore clean - without any reference to results on target. My point here is that if you aren't looking at the results of the cleaning, you just don't know what works to get the bore clean or not.
Barrels often have preferred states of cleanliness, based on targets. A bore scope can tell you if you are hitting that goal or if things are stacking up gradually changing the after cleaning condition. If you are shooting competition you really want to avoid having a barrel stop shooting in the middle of a match, and then having no way to determine whether its degree of cleanliness is the reason. The thing that I particularly like about the Teslong bore scopes is that as cheap as they are, there is no reason not to take them to the range.
 
Wonder how @FrankG feels about iosso on a brush?

LOL! I have been shocking Frank for a long time. However, I really only care what my target and borescope tell me. Frank will probably survive my shocking cleaning methods.

From my targets and borescope I can say with high certainty that Iosso on an Iosso brush is very aggressive and should be used infrequently when other methods fail. I can also say with high certainty that a bronze brush works very well and doesn't harm bores.

The case Frank likes to bring up is the genius who heavily cleaned his barrel with JB something like every 11 rounds and in 250 rounds the barrel was toast. A similar case is the guy who spun a nylon brush on a drill to see what happened to on old barrel. It should be very obvious why those two cases came out the way they did.........

;)
 
Last edited:
I treat everyone the same, doesn't matter if it's a 6bra or 338 lapua imp. Montana extreme copper killer (best carbon solvent I know of) and a bronze brush. 2 wet patches followed by 10 brush strokes, 2 or 3 cycles of that and I'm done. They get cleaned after every range session whether its 15 rounds or 50.
Not sure if I'm reading correctly, but are you saying that Montana Extreme copper killer is actually the best "carbon" remover you know of? Cause I'm always looking for more effective carbon removers (copper is easy to remove/dissolve...but not carbon). If so, I need to try!

Also, as for bronze brushing and crowns...what type of crown do you prefer...beveled or square?

Thanks!
 
Not sure if I'm reading correctly, but are you saying that Montana Extreme copper killer is actually the best "carbon" remover you know of? Cause I'm always looking for more effective carbon removers (copper is easy to remove/dissolve...but not carbon). If so, I need to try!

Also, as for bronze brushing and crowns...what type of crown do you prefer...beveled or square?

Thanks!
Yes, thats what Im saying. Crowns, I do a chamfer on hunting rifles and square on bench guns. But the most successful br rifle of them all had a chamfer. It doesnt matter if your indicated in right.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RAG
LOL! I have been shocking Frank for a long time. However, I really only care what my target and borescope tell me. Frank will probably survive my shocking cleaning methods.

From my targets and borescope I can say with high certainty that Iosso on an Iosso brush is very aggressive and should be used infrequently when other methods fail. I can also say with high certainty that a bronze brush works very well and doesn't harm bores.

The case Frank likes to bring up is the genius who heavily cleaned his barrel with JB something like every 11 rounds and in 250 rounds the barrel was toast. A similar case is the guy who spun a nylon brush on a drill to see what happened to on old barrel. It should be very obvious why those two cases came out the way they did.........

;)
When I've used Iosso on a brush and with 30 or so full strokes every couple hundred rounds [so, maybe 10-15 times on a barrel] I have never seen any gouges or scratches in or across the lands or grooves. I just have a hard time imagining how Iosso/JB/Flitz/KG 2 would make those deep gouges in the pics.
 
When I've used Iosso on a brush and with 30 or so full strokes every couple hundred rounds [so, maybe 10-15 times on a barrel] I have never seen any gouges or scratches in or across the lands or grooves. I just have a hard time imagining how Iosso/JB/Flitz/KG 2 would make those deep gouges in the pics.
I did one with a piloted 60deg center cutter one time and it made no difference
 
Yes, thats what Im saying. Crowns, I do a chamfer on hunting rifles and square on bench guns. But the most successful br rifle of them all had a chamfer. It doesnt matter if your indicated in right.
This sure seems to be one of those things where there is no one right way to skin this cat! By hunting rifles, would you include squirrel/prairie guns in that as well, where a typical shooter might expect a 1-12 or 1-14 6BR to go 5,000+ rounds?

How deep do you like ro chamfer, and piloted?

Thanks!
 
This sure seems to be one of those things where there is no one right way to skin this cat! By hunting rifles, would you include squirrel/prairie guns in that as well, where a typical shooter might expect a 1-12 or 1-14 6BR to go 5,000+ rounds?

How deep do you like ro chamfer, and piloted?

Thanks!
The chamfer is mainly for rifles that will be handled a little rough. A bench gun goes from a case to the bench and thats about it. Plus those guys are careful about cleaning. The chamfer is more durable than a sharp crown as well. If you were going to put 5k rounds on a 6br I would chamfer it. Just enough to break the edge, single point cermet insert in the lathe.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: RAG

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
165,335
Messages
2,193,896
Members
78,849
Latest member
wiltbk421
Back
Top