Fair enough, let me help you out.
I did not start any argument nor did I ever call into question the legality of the thick carpets with grooves in them. I measured my words precisely; I made a comment that they "give me pause" when I see them used, but I never questioned them nor called them out to officials.
In this thread, all I have been talking about is my experience with the new JOYpod feet and how they work for me. It's disconcerting that I was quickly attacked and impugned for my report. It was even suggested by Otis that I should get a carpet as this would help to control the hop. Then you called into question the legality of my setup because it was not a carpet but rather a slick surface.
WWT, please take a step back. You can continue to use your thick carpet, it doesn't bother me; never did. As for the NRA rules, as usual, they are so badly written, they contradict themselves and then there up for interpretation by someone at some point and then we get a different ruling at another time, another venue.
I had a fun time shooting today; it was nice not to have to worry about the line and just concentrate on shooting. I'm getting my new load up to speed and that's helping a lot. I totally get about spending more time behind a rifle to get better at it; but unfortunately that's just not reality for me. I only get to shoot about once a month at these matches. I'm running to the airport in the morning. Again.
Bottom line though is that I really like the new feet from Seb.