Discussion in 'Gear Talk: What to Buy? and Gear Evaluations' started by onelastshot, Aug 8, 2019.
I've been carrying a Buck "Muskcrat" for years. Can't lose it because they dom't make them anymore.
Case Granddaddy Barlow-----if you can find one.
I have bought decent $30 Chinese knives. Anything cheaper (including free) has been disappointing in one or many aspects. I have bought good US made folding knives with good steel for $60, probably a few cheaper and a handful in the $90-240 range.
The $210 that spread covers buys a lot of quality, fit and finish, design and better materials. On the other hand, they are all production knives, not custom. A nice custom folder starts around $500 and the sky is the limit, $1,000+ is common and $4,000 is not unheard of.
It's like a Rolex vs a Seiko vs a Casio vs something out of a Cracker Jack box.
They all tell time (hopefully) and there is plenty of justification at each price point.
The $135 dollar (clearance price) US made knife I just ordered won 2013 Blade Show Knife of the Year. The closest an NRA giveaway knife can get to an award is if you cut one out of a can of PBR.
You might not notice the difference opening up an Amazon box but if you ever use it more strenuously and pay attention, you would see.
Yes I'm still reading these and yes I purchased a knife, a CiViVi, Courser. With shipping it was $70.00.
My Wilson Combat Hogue knife just arrived.
The handle is very comfortable, it is nice and flickable, locks up tight. I can see that there are steel reinforcements inside the G10 handle slabs but the only thing you touch is the nicely contoured G10 and the pocket clip which you barely notice.
It's the 4" blade model and it is pretty big, the 3.5" model would be plenty big for most purposes and a little more discreet but that wasn't on sale.
The only negative I see so far is that the left handed side of the ambi-thumb stud hangs up a little on my pocket. Maybe it's just better retention? Not a big deal and might make it less likely to fall out of my pocket.
I've never seen a China knife that can compare.
It's nicer than the Benchmades that I now regret purchasing.
I like the spider hole and ball bearing lock of my Spyderco Manix a lot but the Hogue ergonomics probably beat it.
The 3.5" version that sells for around $200 looks like it would be a damn good deal for anyone that wants to step up in to a high end production knife.
At $140 shipped, the one I got was a great deal.
There are reasons why a custom folder can cost $1,000 or more but I don't think many people would feel like this Hogue is not a worthy EDC.
A Good buddy of mine just started repping for Hogue knifes & grips this year. I got to help him select the samples for his display cases. For the money right now I would say Hogue is one of the best made USA knifes. Really well built. They have a certain heft, a feel of solid quality. Plenty Sharp from the factory. The folders have a great safety feature built right in. mike in ct
How about a Benchmade Mini-Grip? Inexpensive at $60, but a great knife, great profile, and the locking mechanism is solid. You might need to sharpen the knife once you receive it - Benchmade isn't known for their factory sharp knives. Overall, it's a great knife that meets all of your needs, and more importantly, you can buy it at most outdoor/knife shops.
But Benchmade is known for contributing to anti-gun lobbying efforts.
I like Spyderco a lot in the $60+ range and there are other quality options as you increase your budget that aren't anti-gun.
I have an inkling that Hogue is never going to be anti-gun...
You got that right. Dam shame about BM knifes. Mike
I think I found a Chinese knife that might match the quality of a good US made knife:
The Reate T4000
It looks very nice but $400.
That gets you Bohler M390 steel and a titanium handle, steel lock insert, ceramic bearings, etc. What got me is the false edge spear point blade grind with central Fuller, very sexy and the way the handle is cut makes the flipper much lower profile.
I have to say I like the push button lock on my Hogue better than the frame lock. I just like a solid handle and it's easier to close one handed. Other than that, it looks really nice.
With that said, I don't have $400 for a pocket knife right now but it's making my short list...
I've carried a small automatic Benchmade for 10 years now. I'd recommend a serrated blade. If you need it and don't have it you're screwed and it doesn't get in the way.
It's my understanding BM contributed to a local politician. Name one politician in Portland that's not anti-gun leaning. Not everything is black and white.
If you've never felt the need to carry before, and you aren't sure what you will do with one now, I suggest the bigger question is get one that won't wear a hole in your pocket.
Carried a CRKT Pazoda now for 6 years on the farm everyday...But when I travel its a Boker Ak47 automatic, Hell of a knife for 30 bucks.
I have one of those Case Shark Tooth's. I have had it since the mid 70's.
sounds about right. the leather case is almost worn through!
I love it. I lost it in a few gut piles but the kids earned $5.00 each time they found it.
I carry a CRKT Provoke Karambit...I know all too well how to deploy it. I wouldn't suggest it unless you are willing to learn. It is for self-defense & maybe freeing yourself from a seatbelt if you find yourself upsidedown ......
I believe the anti-benchmade propoganda is just that. Ignore it.
I have about 2 dozen knives. I sharpen them all every 6 months or so and then swap them out as they get dull. I consider a knife dull if you can't shave with it.
I wanted to add to this thread that if automatic knives are legal where you live, get one. they are much more convenient. If not, then get something you can open with one hand, either spring assisted or just easy to open with a flick.
I like the zero tolerance with the flipper on the back as well.
I sharpen with a wicked edge.
Not really a knife guy, but a few thoughts.
- got a 6-8 benchmades. Most are axis locks. Luv the axis for everything except field dressing. Then I go fixed.
- heard the lefty banter on BM. Don’t like it, but don’t know the truth.
- benchmade cannot grind both sides of their blades within 5 degrees of each other.
- got a few bucks. Their 420 can go smoken sharp with 1000 grit followed w 4 micron on a leather strop, but won’t last long.
- like s30 and cpm 154 for holding a working edge.
I carry a BM 940 95% of the time. Outstanding pocket knife.
Gerber has USA made knives
Carried this one for decades.
Separate names with a comma.